Developing a model for progressing and monitoring governance, leadership and accountability for urban health: A case study from Guatemala

Participating institutions name and acronyms

Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine

CIIPEC

CIIPEC Researchers

Guillermo Hegel – Principal Investigator

Yaimie López – Research Assistant

 

Abstract

Many countries are in the process of developing comprehensive health systems to achieve Universal Health Coverage. Within urban centers this task is more complex due to the plethora of health providers and actors from other sectors with influence on the social determinants of health and subsequent health inequities. This means that municipal governments and Ministry of Health must have strong governance, leadership, accountability and multisectorial action (GLAMSA) structures to ensure the most disadvantaged of people living in cities have fair access to health and health care. This projects uses the Participatory Action Research Approach to develop an assessment tool about GLAMSA to design a model to identify, measure and monitor mechanisms to improve governance, leadership and accountability policies and practices within urban municipal health systems in two municipalities of Guatemala.

 

General objective

To develop an assessment tool about health governance, leadership, accountability and multisectoral (GLAMSA) action that will identify, measure and monitor mechanisms to improve GLAMSA policies and practices within urban municipal health systems.

 

Methodology

We are applying the Participatory Action Research (PAR) approach in all the stages of the project. PAR is a cyclical research process of problem identification, action and reflection leading to further inquiry and action for change through democratic processes of decision making. This approach is gaining popularity as a mechanism for strengthening health systems and improving health program delivery in low-and-middle income settings.

 

Along with co-researchers from two municipalities, we are co-developing a qualitative web-based tool to assess governance, leadership, accountability and multisectoral action (GLAMSA) and to devise an improvement process that is specifically for use within urban municipalities. Data collection includes identifying documents, policies and procedures for review, a participatory discussion from a wide range of stakeholders about the functioning of these documents, and consideration of the internal and external relations that have an impact on the overarching GLAMSA domain. This information is then collected and summarized for a final stage of subjective internal review to rank performance in each area. Performance rankings are optimal, suboptimal, medium, and minimal. After ranking performance, the stakeholders identify priorities for low performing areas and actions for improvement which can be monitored and progressed over time.

 

Project duration



Scientific publications

15 months (Sept 2019 – Nov 2020)

 


Can everyone hear me? Reflections on the use of global online workshops for promoting inclusive knowledge generation